Nick’s Pizzeria Menu (Update 2025)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Nick's Pizzeria in Clayton, NJ offers a wide variety of pizzas, from classic cheese to specialty options like buffalo chicken and BBQ chicken. The restaurant also serves sandwiches, strombolis, and pasta dishes. Customers rave about the generous portions and affordable prices. The crumbled sausage on the meat lovers pizza is a standout, according to one review. The casual and welcoming atmosphere makes it a great spot for families and groups. With options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery, Nick's Pizzeria caters to a range of preferences. The authentic Italian flavors and friendly service make it a go-to spot for delicious and satisfying meals.

Pizzas Specialty Pizzas Slice Side Orders Panzarotti Salads-Soups Steaks Sandwiches Wraps Burgers Stromboli Quesadillas Cold Subs Clubs Wings Wing Sauces Dinners Small Appetites Miscellaneous Dinners Kids Menu Drinks 20 oz. Soda Sodas

Pizzas

12" Pizza Sauce and Cheese
$9.50

Medium Pizza Sauce and Cheese
$12.25

Large Pizza Sauce and Cheese
$14.50

Extra Large 18" Pizza Sauce and Cheese
$16.50

Square Pizza Sauce and Cheese
$17.00

Giant Pizza Sauce and Cheese
$26.00

12" Buffalo Chicken

Grilled chicken with buffalo sauce and blue cheese topped with moz cheese.
$11.50

Medium Buffalo Chicken

Grilled chicken with buffalo sauce and blue cheese topped with moz cheese.
$16.25

Large Buffalo Chicken

Grilled chicken with buffalo sauce and blue cheese topped with moz cheese.
$16.50

Extra Large 18" Buffalo Chicken

Grilled chicken with buffalo sauce and blue cheese topped with moz cheese.
$18.50

12" B B Q Chicken

BBQ sauce, cheese, chicken, sweet peppers, onions.
$11.50

Medium B B Q Chicken

BBQ sauce, cheese, chicken, sweet peppers, onions.
$16.25

Large B B Q Chicken

BBQ sauce, cheese, chicken, sweet peppers, onions.
$16.50

Extra Large 18" B B Q Chicken

BBQ sauce, cheese, chicken, sweet peppers, onions.
$18.50

12" Chicken Parm Pizza

Breaded chicken.
$12.50

Medium Chicken Parm Pizza

Breaded chicken.
$17.25

Large Chicken Parm Pizza

Breaded chicken.
$19.50

Extra Large 18" Chicken Parm Pizza

Breaded chicken.
$22.00

12" The Works

Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, onions.
$14.50

Medium The Works

Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, onions.
$18.25

Large The Works

Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, onions.
$20.50

Extra Large 18" The Works

Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, onions.
$23.50

12" Hawaiin

Ham, pineapple, cheese.
$11.50

Medium Hawaiin

Ham, pineapple, cheese.
$16.25

Large Hawaiin

Ham, pineapple, cheese.
$18.50

Extra Large 18" Hawaiin

Ham, pineapple, cheese.
$21.00

12" Meat Lovers

Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, bacon, ham.
$14.50

Medium Meat Lovers

Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, bacon, ham.
$18.25

Large Meat Lovers

Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, bacon, ham.
$20.50

Extra Large 18" Meat Lovers

Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, bacon, ham.
$23.50

12" Chick Bacon Rancher

Chicken, bacon.
$12.50

Medium Chick Bacon Rancher

Chicken, bacon.
$17.25

Large Chick Bacon Rancher

Chicken, bacon.
$19.50

Extra Large 18" Chick Bacon Rancher

Chicken, bacon.
$22.00

12" Veggie Lovers

Mushrooms, black olives, tomatoes, broccoli, green peppers, onions, cheese.
$12.50

Medium Veggie Lovers

Mushrooms, black olives, tomatoes, broccoli, green peppers, onions, cheese.
$17.25

Large Veggie Lovers

Mushrooms, black olives, tomatoes, broccoli, green peppers, onions, cheese.
$19.50

Extra Large 18" Veggie Lovers

Mushrooms, black olives, tomatoes, broccoli, green peppers, onions, cheese.
$22.00

12" Greek

Tomatoes, greek olives, roasted peppers, feta cheese, olive oil.
$12.50

Medium Greek

Tomatoes, greek olives, roasted peppers, feta cheese, olive oil.
$17.25

Large Greek

Tomatoes, greek olives, roasted peppers, feta cheese, olive oil.
$19.50

Extra Large 18" Greek

Tomatoes, greek olives, roasted peppers, feta cheese, olive oil.
$22.00

12" Chz Steak Hoagie

Steak, tomatoes, lettuce, onions.
$12.50

Medium Chz Steak Hoagie

Steak, tomatoes, lettuce, onions.
$17.25

Large Chz Steak Hoagie

Steak, tomatoes, lettuce, onions.
$19.50

Extra Large 18" Chz Steak Hoagie

Steak, tomatoes, lettuce, onions.
$22.00

12" Margarita

Thin crust.
$11.50

Medium Margarita

Thin crust.
$16.25

Large Margarita

Thin crust.
$18.50

Extra Large 18" Margarita

Thin crust.
$21.00

12" Bianca Trio

Cheese, ricotta, garlic oil.
$13.50

Medium Bianca Trio

Cheese, ricotta, garlic oil.
$17.25

Large Bianca Trio

Cheese, ricotta, garlic oil.
$19.50

Extra Large 18" Bianca Trio

Cheese, ricotta, garlic oil.
$22.00

Specialty Pizzas

Slice

Cheese
$2.34

French Fries

Salt.
$5.25

Cheese Fries

Cheddar cheese on side.
$6.50

Curly Fries
$6.00

Steak Cut Fries
$6.00

Small Fries

Salt.
$3.95

Onion Rings
$7.00

6 Piece Mozz Sticks

Pizza sauce.
$7.50

Fried Mushrooms
$7.00

Jalapeno Poppers

Spaghetti sauce.
$7.50

Garlic Bread
$1.50

Mega Fries

Bacon, cheddar & mozz cheese. Served with ranch on side.
$8.50

Chicken Tenders
$8.00

Old Bay Fries

Old bay.
$5.25

Side Meatballs
$1.60

6 Piece Butterfly Shrimp

Cocktail sauce.
$9.50

Fried Pickle Spears

Horseradish mayo.
$6.75

Zucchini Sticks

Spaghetti sauce.
$6.50

3 Piece Chicken Tender with Fries

3 tenders with fries
$7.99

4 Piece Tenders with Fries

Fries.
$10.00

6 Piece Tenders with Fries

Fries.
$13.00

12 Piece Nuggets with Fries

12 chicken nuggets with fries.
$10.00

Potato Skins

Bacon, cheddar cheese and sour cream.
$8.50

2 Piece Cheese Steak Egg Rolls
$7.95

Side Orders

Panzarotti

Panzarotti
$7.50

Tossed Salad

Lettuce, tomato, onions, cucumbers, croutons, roll.
$6.50

Large Chef's Salad

Lettuce, tomato, onions, cucumbers, croutons, hot peppers, sweet peppers, sliced pickles, egg, import ham, chopped ham, cooked salami, american, mozzarella, roll.
$8.75

Antipasto Salad

Lettuce, tomato, onions, cucumbers, croutons, hot peppers, sweet peppers, sliced pickles, egg, imported ham, genoa salami, capicolla ham, provolone, mozzarella and roll.
$8.75

Greek Salad

Lettuce, tomato, onions, cucumbers, croutons, Greek olives, egg, pepperoncini peppers, green peppers, feta and roll.
$8.75

Greek with Chicken Salad

Lettuce, tomato, onions, cucumbers, croutons, pepperoncini peppers, green peppers, greek olives, chicken, egg, feta and roll.
$10.25

Caesar Salad

Romaine, Parmesan, croutons and roll.
$7.25

Caesar with Chicken Salad

Romaine, Parmesan, croutons and roll.
$8.75

Spicy Chicken Salad

Romaine, croutons, bread chicken and hot sauce.
$8.75

Turkey Salad

Lettuce, tomato, onions, cucumbers, croutons, turkey, hot peppers, sweet peppers, sliced pickles, egg, American, mozzarella and roll.
$8.75

Cranberry Walnut Salad
$10.00

Side Salad

Lettuce, tomato, onions, cucumbers.
$3.75

Julienne Salad

Lettuce, tomato, onions, import ham, green peppers, turkey, egg, Swiss and roll.
$8.75

Oriental Chicken

Romaine, red cabbage, carrots, almonds, breaded chick, mandarins, wonton strips, asian sesame and roll.
$10.25

Cobb
$10.50

Salads-Soups

Steaks

Steak

Steak.
$7.75

Cheese Steak

American and Steak.
$7.50

Cheese Steak Sub

Sub roll, american, lettuce, tomato, raw onions, oregano & steak.
$7.75

Chicken Steak

Chicken.
$6.75

Chicken Cheese Steak

American and chicken.
$7.25

Chicken Cheese Steak Sub

Sub roll, american, lettuce, tomato, raw onions, oregano & chicken.
$7.50

Pizza Steak

Mozzarella, pizza sauce, pizza sauce and steak.
$7.50

Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak

Sub roll, american, hot sauce, blue cheese & chicken.
$7.50

Steak Egg & Cheese

Steak egg american cheese.
$8.50

Meatball Sandwich

Sub roll, spaghetti sauce and meatball.
$6.00

Sausage

Sub roll, spaghetti sauce and sausage.
$6.25

Chicken Parm

Sub roll, provolone, spaghetti sauce & breaded chicken.
$7.50

Flounder Sandwich

Sub roll and flounder.
$6.75

Cheeseburger Sub

3 patties on a long roll with american cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & oregano.
$9.00

Grilled Chicken

Sub roll and grilled chicken.
$6.50

Breaded Chicken

Sub roll and breaded chicken.
$6.50

Hot Roast Beef Sandwich

Sub roll and hot roast beef.
$8.25

Eggplant Parm Sandwich

Sub roll, provolone, spaghetti sauce and breaded eggplant.
$6.50

Peppers & Egg Sandwich

Sub roll.
$5.75

Gyro

Pita bread, tomato, onions, tzatziki sauce and fries.
$9.75

Original Chicken Sandwich

Crispy chicken patty served on a potato roll with a pickle.
$6.50

Sandwiches

Wraps

Buffalo Chick Wrap

Chicken steak, American, buffalo sauce and blue cheese.
$10.75

Chick Ranch Wrap

Grilled chicken, bacon, American and ranch.
$10.75

Chicken Caesar Wrap

Grilled chicken, grated cheese, romaine lettuce and Caesar.
$10.75

Club Wrap

Ham, turkey, bacon, American, lettuce, tomato and mayo.
$10.75

Crispy Chick Wrap

Breaded chicken, provolone and honey mustard.
$10.75

Roast Beef Wrap

Roast beef, provolone, mayo, horseradish, black pepper, raw onions, lettuce and tomato.
$10.75

Tuna Wrap

Tuna, American, lettuce and tomato.
$10.75

Southwest Wrap

Grilled chicken, American, chipotle sauce, bacon, roasted peppers, lettuce, tomato and red onions.
$10.75

Veggie Wrap

Lettuce, tomato, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, broccoli and olives.
$10.75

California Wrap

Grilled chicken, pepper jack, mayo, avocado, lettuce, tomato and bacon.
$10.75

Mediterranean Wrap

Grilled chicken, feta, shredded lettuce, tomato, raw onions, cucumbers, Greek olives and Greek dressing.
$10.75

Hamburger

Round roll, fries and hamburger.
$7.75

Cheeseburger

Round roll, American, fries and hamburger.
$8.25

Bacon Ch Burg

2 hamburger patties with bacon & American cheese.
$9.00

Pizza Burger

Burger topped with pizza sauce & mozzarella cheese.
$8.25

Nick's Burger

Russian dressing, lettuce, cheese, onions & pickles.
$8.50

Cheeseburger Deluxe

Lettuce, tomato, onions & pickles.
$8.50

Cowboy Burger

Cheddar cheese, BBQ sauce, bacon & topped with an onion ring.
$9.25

Alpine Burger

Swiss cheese, mushroom, fried onions & mayo.
$8.75

Sunny Burger

Crispy bacon, sunny side up egg & cheese.
$9.50

Hawaii Burger

Pineapple, teriyaki, bacon and onion ring on top.
$9.25

California Burger

Pepper jack, fries, bacon, lettuce, tomato, raw onions, guacamole and mayo.
$9.25

C B O Burger

Aged cheddar, bacon and caramelized onions.
$9.00

Burgers

Stromboli

Meat Lovers

Cheese, spaghetti sauce, bacon, ham, sausage, pepperoni, meatball.
$14.75

Steak Stromboli

Spaghetti sauce, cheese, steak, green peppers, onions.
$14.00

Chicken Stromboli

Chicken, green peppers, onions.
$13.50

Italian Stromboli

Imported ham, capicolla, genoa, green peppers, onions.
$13.50

Buffalo Chicken Stromboli

Chicken.
$13.50

Supreme

Chicken, broccoli, sweet peppers, mushrooms, onions.
$14.50

Veggie Stromboli

Green peppers, onions, mushrooms, tomatoes, black olives, broccoli.
$13.50

Calzone
$11.75

Turnover
$10.75

Buffalo Chick Quesadilla

Moz cheese, chicken, buffalo sauce and blue cheese.
$9.50

Cheese Quesadillas

Moz cheese, pepper jack, tomatoes, sour cream and salsa.
$8.75

Chicken Quesadillas

Moz cheese, pepper jack, tomatoes, chicken, sour cream and salsa.
$9.50

Veggie Quesadillas

Moz cheese, pepper jack, tomatoes, fried onions, mushrooms, black olives, green peppers, sour cream and salsa.
$9.25

Steak Quesadilla

Moz cheese, steak, onions, salsa and sour cream.
$9.50

Quesadillas

Cold Subs

American Cold Sub

Sub roll, American, lettuce, tomato, raw onions, oregano, import ham, pressed ham and cooked salami.
$6.75

Italian Cold Sub

Sub roll, provolone, lettuce, tomato, raw onions, oregano, import ham, capicolla and genoa.
$7.00

Tuna Cold Sub

Sub roll, lettuce, tomato, raw onions, oregano and tuna sld.
$7.00

Ham & Cheese Cold Sub

Sub roll, American, lettuce, tomato, raw onions, oregano and ham.
$7.00

Roast Beef Cold Sub

Sub roll, lettuce, tomato, raw onions, oregano and roast beef.
$8.00

Mixed Cheese Cold Sub

Sub roll, American, provolone, lettuce, tomato, raw onions and oregano.
$6.50

Turkey Cold Sub

Sub roll, lettuce, tomato, raw onions, oregano and roast turkey.
$7.50

Chicken Salad Cold Sub

Sub roll, lettuce, tomato, raw onions, oregano and chicken sld.
$6.75

Egg Salad Cold Sub

Egg salad on a roll.
$5.25

Blt Sub

Sub roll, bacon, lettuce, tomato & mayo.
$7.00

Turkey Club

Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, french fries, mayo and toasted.
$10.99

B.L.T. Club

Bacon, lettuce, tomato, french fries, toasted and mayo.
$10.99

Tuna Club

Bacon, lettuce, tomato, french fries, toasted, mayo and tuna.
$10.99

Ham & Cheese Club

Bacon, lettuce, tomato, french fries, toasted, mayo and ham.
$10.99

Roast Beef Club

Bacon, lettuce, tomato, french fries, toasted, mayo and roast beef.
$10.99

Cheese Steak Club

Bacon, lettuce, tomato, french fries, toasted, mayo and steak.
$10.99

Chick Salad Club

White brd, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo & chick salad.
$10.99

The Dagwood

Swiss, ham, turkey, shred lettuce, tomato, bacon, french fries, mayo and toasted.
$10.99

Cheeseburger Club

American, burger, bacon, tomato, lettuce, french fries, mayo and toasted.
$10.99

Grilled Chicken Club

Grilled chicken, tomato, lettuce, bacon, french fries, mayo, toasted
$10.99

Clubs

Wings

6 Piece Wings
$7.75

12 Piece Wings
$14.50

50 Piece Wings
$55.00

10 Piece Boneless Wings
$9.00

20 Piece Boneless Wings
$17.00

30 Piece Boneless Wings
$25.00

Original Sauce
$0.50

Mild Sauce
$0.50

Garlic Parm
$0.50

Honey BBQ
$0.50

BBQ Sauce
$0.50

Sweet N Spicy Sauce
$0.50

Sweet Teriyaki
$0.50

Mango Habanero Sauce
$0.50

Blue Cheese Dressing
$1.00

Ranch Dressing
$0.50

Celery
$0.50

Wing Sauces

Dinners

Baked Ziti

Garlic bread, ricotta and mozzarella.
$11.00

Spaghetti

Spag sauce and garlic bread.
$10.50

Cheese Ravioli

Spag sauce, mozz cheese and garlic bread.
$11.25

Eggplant Parm

Spaghetti sauce, provolone and garlic bread.
$11.50

Fried Flounder

Tartar sauce.
$11.00

Butterfly Shrimp

Coctail sauce.
$12.00

Penne Pasta

Spag sauce and garlic bread.
$10.50

Shrimp Parm

Provolone, spaghetti sauce and garlic bread.
$12.50

B.L.T.

White brd, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo and toasted.
$4.75

Grilled Cheese

White brd, american and toasted.
$3.75

Hot Dog

Bun.
$1.75

Egg Salad

On sliced bread.
$3.75

Chicken Salad

On sliced bread.
$3.75

Small Appetites

Miscellaneous

Ketchup

Free.
$0.00

Cheese Sos
$1.25

Dressing
$0.75

Menu

Free.
$0.00

Roll
$0.50

Butter

Free.
$0.00

1 Piece Breaded Chicken
$1.75

1 Piece Grilled Chicken
$2.50

Tuna Salad
$2.50

3 Piece Kids Chicken Tender with Fries

3 tenders with fries.
$7.99

Kids Grilled Cheese with Fries

Grilled cheese with fries.
$6.99

2 Piece Kids Hotdogs with Fries

2 hotdogs with fries.
$6.99

Kids Cheeseburger with Fries

Fries, potato roll, american.
$7.99

Kids Spag with 2 Piece Meatballs

Small portion of spaghetti with 2 meatballs & garlic bread.
$6.99

Kids Spag with Butter & Parm Cheese

Small portion of spaghetti with butter and parmesan cheese & garlic bread.
$4.75

6 Piece Kids Nuggets with Fries

6 chicken nuggets with fries.
$6.99

12 Piece Kids Nuggets with Fries

12 chicken nuggets with fries.
$10.00

3 Piece Kids Raviolis with 2 Piece Meatballs

3 cheese raviolis with 2 meatballs & garlic bread.
$6.99

Kids 10" Pizza

Pizza sauce and cheese.
$6.99

Dinners Kids Menu

Drinks

Bottled Water

20 ounces.
$1.00

Pepsi, 20 oz.
$2.50

Diet Pepsi, 20 oz.
$2.50

Ginger Ale, 20 oz.
$2.50

Cherry Pepsi, 20 oz.
$2.50

Mountain Dew, 20 oz.
$2.50

Tea - Lemon, 18.5 oz.
$2.50

Tea - Sweet , 18.5 oz.
$2.50

Pepsi Zero, 20 oz.
$2.50

Starry, 20 oz.
$2.50

Apple Juice, 15.2 oz.
$2.50

Cran - Grape, 15.2 oz.
$2.50

Cranberry, 15.2 oz.
$2.50

Tea - Peach, 18.5 oz.
$2.50

Root Beer, 20 oz.
$2.50

20 oz. Soda

Sodas

2 Liter Pepsi
$3.50

2 Liter Diet Pepsi
$3.50

2 Liter Pepsi Zero
$3.50

2 Liter Ginger Ale
$3.50

2 Liter Mountain Dew
$3.50

2 Liter Iced Tea
$3.50

2 Liter Cherry Pepsi
$3.50

2 Liter Orange
$3.50

2 Liter Grape
$3.50