• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Nick’s Pizzeria

Nick’s Pizzeria in Clayton, NJ is a beloved spot for pizza lovers. Offering a variety of specialty pizzas, from classic pepperoni to unique buffalo chicken and BBQ chicken options, Nick’s ensures a flavorful experience. Customers rave about the generous portion sizes and affordable prices. The crumbled sausage on the meat lovers pizza is a standout, surprising taste buds with its savory goodness. With a casual yet classy atmosphere and excellent service, Nick’s Pizzeria is the perfect place for a family meal or a quick bite with friends. Don't miss out on this local gem for delicious Italian pizzas and more.

LOCATIONS

Welcome to Nick’s Pizzeria, a beloved Italian pizza restaurant located in Clayton, NJ. With a wide range of pizza options, from classic cheese to specialty creations like Buffalo Chicken and BBQ Chicken, Nick’s Pizzeria offers something for every pizza lover.

Customers rave about the quality and taste of the food at Nick’s Pizzeria. One reviewer mentioned the nostalgia of enjoying a meal at Nick’s since childhood, while another highlighted the excellent pizza, Stromboli, and sandwiches. The affordability of the menu was also praised, with generous portions that won’t break the bank.

One standout feature of Nick’s Pizzeria is the crumbled sausage on the Meat Lovers pizza, which surprised and delighted customers with its unique flavor. The attention to detail and quality ingredients set Nick’s Pizzeria apart from other pizza places in the area.

Whether you’re looking for a casual lunch spot, a place to cater an event, or a cozy dinner spot with waiter service, Nick’s Pizzeria has you covered. With a range of utilities including delivery, takeout, and reservations, Nick’s Pizzeria makes it easy to enjoy delicious Italian pizza in a relaxed and inviting atmosphere.

Next time you’re in Clayton, NJ, be sure to stop by Nick’s Pizzeria for a slice of pizza that will exceed your expectations and leave you craving more.

START YOUR REVIEW OF Nick’s Pizzeria
Donnell O.
Donnell O.

A classic place from my childhood, still one of the most special cheesesteaks. There's lots to love about this place and I do. I'm passing this affinity down to my kids. They love it too

Michael O.
Michael O.

Can't beat Nicks in Clayton, excellent pizza, Stromboli's and sandwiches, I highly recommend

David R.
David R.

Rather generic run of the mill pizza places(but in a good way) in clayton. Felt like the kinda places I'd go after school with my lunch money lol. Slices were big and 2 plain slices and a drink came to less than $6. You can't find that much food for prices like that these days. This hit the spot and was exactly what I was hoping for. Birch beer in the fountain soda was a plus to me.

Mark P.
Mark P.

I stopped one day & got a pizza cheese steak sandwich, tasted great, 2 days later I went back for spaghetti & meatballs, they give you plenty of meatballs & sauce. Tasted pretty good

Sara G.
Sara G.

The pizza was great here. But what I tell you was fantastic was the crumbled sausage on the meat lovers pizza. I was pleasantly surprised on that sausage It was a little bit of a shock to my taste buds cuz I definitely wasn't expecting sausage to taste like that on a pizza so I recommend if you can eat pork to get a pepperoni sausage pizza from there. Now I don't know what their meatballs taste like that comes on meat lover's Pizza cuz I had them take it off. I mean it could have surprised me like the sausage did but I didn't give it a chance to cause anywhere else I've ever let the meatballs stay on a meat lovers They weren't good so I wasn't about to let them ruin the pizza I was getting while visiting. But I definitely recommend getting whatever pizza you're getting and having sausage on it